• RFQs and communication
  • Global buyers · suppliers in mainland China

How to Compare Supplier Quotations on the Same Basis

Short answer

Start with scope, then compare price. Put each offer against the same product revision, quantity, currency and named inclusions. Keep missing costs as unknowns, show additions separately and resolve material gaps before ranking suppliers.

Where this applies: Global goods sourcing, especially offers from mainland China; excludes destination duties, tax calculations and interpretation of trade terms.

Checklists and examples are Shop8 editorial recommendations. Reviewed by a separate AI agent in a separate context; the same model family was used. No human editorial review has been completed.

In this guide
  1. Set the comparison basis before entering prices
  2. Build four comparison blocks
  3. Worked example: a cheaper unit price can produce a higher quoted subtotal
  4. Give unknowns their own column
  5. Rank only after resolving decision-changing gaps
  6. Comparison limits and your next step
  7. Sources

Set the comparison basis before entering prices

This Shop8 method is for buyers who already have supplier offers and need to decide which deserve further discussion. Write a one-line baseline above the sheet: item revision, order quantity, currency, packaging requirement and required completion milestone. Keep alternatives on separate rows. If one offer uses a different currency, record the conversion date and rate you chose and keep the original amount visible.

ITA's quotation-field checklist includes unit and extended prices, a delivery point, estimated shipping date and validity date. ITA pro forma invoice guidance provides a useful field reference; it is not a universal quotation format.

Build four comparison blocks

  1. Product match: record the specification revision and whether each offered configuration matches it. Separate a proposed substitute from the baseline.
  2. Commercial scope: record the quantity basis, included packaging and separately quoted work. Label a missing line “not stated,” not zero.
  3. Timing: record the exact completion event, start conditions and unresolved approvals. A number of days without a starting event stays unconfirmed.
  4. Evidence and exceptions: link to the quotation and clarification revision. Record which differences affect your decision and who is resolving them.

Worked example: a cheaper unit price can produce a higher quoted subtotal

This invented example uses the same currency, item revision, quantity and named supply boundary for both offers. It is a quoted-scope comparison, not a delivered-cost estimate.

FieldOffer AOffer B
Quantity500 units500 units
Unit price2.402.55
Goods subtotal1,2001,275
Required packaging100 separatelyIncluded
Comparable quoted subtotal1,3001,275

On these stated inputs, B is 25 lower for the compared scope. That does not make B the better supplier. You still need to consider product fit, timing, evidence and unresolved exclusions.

Give unknowns their own column

Use three distinct states for each cost or requirement: included, confirmed additional amount or not stated. If A has not answered whether the requested carton is included, do not copy a guessed allowance into A's official quoted subtotal. You may build a separate planning scenario, but label its assumptions and keep it apart from the supplier-confirmed figures.

Do the same with timing and minimum quantities. An offer that only applies to 2,000 units should not receive the same price score as one that applies to the 500 units you intend to buy. Ask for a matching scenario or leave it outside that comparison.

Rank only after resolving decision-changing gaps

Use a short gate list before a weighted score: exact product scope confirmed, required quantity available and a schedule you can evaluate. Decide your gates before looking at the lowest price. Keep an offer on hold when a gate is unknown; distinguish that from a confirmed failure.

Once offers pass the gates, record the tradeoff behind your preference. For example: “Preferred for further evaluation because the required packaging is included and the completion milestone is confirmed; product evidence remains to be checked.” This makes the reason reviewable without presenting a preliminary ranking as approval.

Comparison limits and your next step

A neat spreadsheet can hide unsupported inputs. Check arithmetic, units and offer validity before sharing a ranking. Do not combine a supplier's confirmed price with guessed freight, tax or destination charges and label the result an authoritative landed cost. Obtain separately scoped advice or quotations for those questions.

Your next action is to send each supplier only its unresolved comparison rows and request a revised quotation reference. Preserve the previous offer, then update the sheet from the revised document. Reopen the ranking when the product version, quantity or major inclusion changes.

Sources and editorial method

Sources support the attributed facts below. The worksheets, examples and decision steps are Shop8 recommendations, rather than requirements issued by these organisations.

  1. [1]
    Pro Forma Invoice — International Trade Administration, U.S. Department of Commerce. Checked 23 October 2026.

Update history

23 October 2026: first draft prepared. 23 October 2026: first publication. Review sooner if a cited source or the buying requirements change.