Sample Approval Checklist: Record Exactly What You Accept
Sources checked 23 October 2026Next review 23 October 2027Published 23 October 2026
Short answer
Approve a sample against named requirements, then record which unit you examined, what you checked, the result and any open exceptions. State whether your decision covers appearance, function, packaging or a narrower question. Shop8 recommends an approval record that a colleague can interpret without seeing the original email conversation.
Where this applies: For business buyers in any destination market working with suppliers in mainland China. This is an operational planning framework; product-specific technical and market requirements need separate review.
Checklists and examples are Shop8 editorial recommendations. Reviewed by a separate AI agent in a separate context; the same model family was used. No human editorial review has been completed.
In this guide
Define the decision before the sample arrives
Use this checklist when a supplier is asking whether to proceed after sending a sample. Start by writing the decision you need: approve the exterior finish, confirm assembly fit, or accept the proposed production configuration. Avoid an unrestricted “sample approved” if you have checked only one feature.
ASQ lists evaluation of supplier samples, including prototyping and testing, among supplier evaluation methods. That supports using evidence from samples, while the record below is Shop8's recommended workflow. Source: ASQ supplier quality.
Identify the reference that everyone will use
- Product name, buyer item code and supplier item code.
- Sample identifier, quantity received and date examined.
- Specification, drawing and artwork revision used for the comparison.
- How the supplier describes the sample's materials and production method.
- Photographs showing the unit, its identifier and relevant details.
- Location and custodian of any retained reference sample.
Ask the supplier to identify differences between this unit and the intended production units. Put “not confirmed” beside an unanswered point. A clear photograph helps locate an issue; use measurements or agreed physical comparisons when the decision depends on dimensions, texture or colour.
Make a requirement-by-requirement record
Use one row per requirement. Record the required outcome, your checking method, the observation and the decision. Keep an observation separate from an interpretation: “lid opens during the agreed handling check” describes a result; “hinge material is wrong” proposes a cause that may still need investigation.
| Requirement | Evidence | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Lid closes flush | Side view and agreed fit check | Accept, reject or pending |
| Logo position | Compare with artwork revision | Record position and result |
| Packaging | Review supplied pack configuration | Approve separately or leave open |
These are worksheet fields, not universal product acceptance criteria. Agree the criteria for your own item with the people responsible for its use.
Worked example: approve the shell, keep the latch open
In a hypothetical project, a buyer receives sample S-04 of a desktop storage case against drawing R3. The buyer accepts the shell dimensions and surface texture. The latch opens during the buyer's agreed handling check, and the final printed sleeve has not arrived.
A useful decision reads: “S-04 shell dimensions and texture accepted against R3. Latch function pending a revised sample. Printed sleeve not assessed. This record does not authorize production of the unresolved configuration.” The supplier is asked to confirm the latch revision and send a new identified unit. This preserves the useful approval without silently accepting two unfinished items.
Choose a status with a precise boundary
Shop8 recommends three simple outcomes: accepted within stated scope, changes required, or pending evidence. If you permit a limited activity while a point remains open, name the activity, quantity or batch and decision owner. Do not leave the supplier to infer permission from a friendly message.
For every exception, assign an owner, due date and required evidence. Identify whether a new physical sample is needed or whether a document correction is sufficient for your decision. Keep commercial questions such as sample fees in their own discussion; this checklist records product approval.
What approval cannot prove and what to do next
The record documents your decision about an identified sample and the checks described. Do not treat it as evidence that unexamined characteristics, later batches or destination-market requirements have been verified. If a technical question is outside your team's capability, leave that point open and ask a suitable specialist what evidence is needed.
Next, send the record and its referenced files together. Ask the supplier to acknowledge the approved configuration and every unresolved item. Save the acknowledgement beside the sample record, then use the same revision identifiers in the production and inspection instructions.
Sources and editorial method
Sources support the attributed facts below. The worksheets, examples and decision steps are Shop8 recommendations, rather than requirements issued by these organisations.
- [1]What is Supplier Quality Management? Supplier Selection Criteria — American Society for Quality (ASQ). Checked 23 October 2026.
Update history
23 October 2026: first draft prepared. 23 October 2026: first publication. Review sooner if a cited source or the buying requirements change.